Do you have to give back an engagement ring after a breakup?

Engagement rings can be an asset all until themselves. The cost of the ‘perfect ring’ can be anywhere from $1,500.00 to well over a million dollars. It all depends on the type of metal used as well as the cut and clarity of the diamond or other precious stones.

Under the circumstances, it is not uncommon for a separating couple to get fixed on the value of an engagement ring and whether to have to legally give the ring back.

In this article, our family lawyers examine legal cases where couples have disputed the ownership of the ring after breaking up.

In case of Papathanasopoulos v Vacopoulos (2007), the Court examined the question being if the engagement ring was given in contemplation of marriage, at what stage might the ring be returned?

Andrew and Vicki where to be married on 6 August 2005, and in anticipation of the marriage, Andrew presented Vicky with an engagement ring valued at $15,250.00. 10 days later, Andrew and Vicki separated, Vicki took off the ring and said to Andrew – “the wedding is off. Here, take the ring, I don’t want it”. Andrew said to Vicki “the ring is a gift, you keep it”.

As neither party wanted the ring, at Vicki’s direction, her father threw the ring in the bin, together with other items that Vicki reminded of Andrew.

Andrew later regretted his decision and wanted the engagement ring returned and eventually commenced court proceedings to recover the ring, or its equivalent value. The basis for the action was that the ring was a conditional gift upon the parties marrying. As the parties did not marry, the conditions had not been met and therefore, Andrew was the rightful owner of the ring.

In response, Vicki argued that the engagement ring was an unconditional gift as Andrew refused to accept the ring after separation and therefore the ring was hers, despite the parties not marrying.

To assist the Court in making a final determination, the Court undertook and extensive review of the principles in the case of Cohen v Stellar (1926), being:

  • If a woman who has received a ring in contemplation of marriage refuses to fulfill the conditions of the gift, she must return it.
  • If a man has, without a recognized legal justification, refuses to carry out his promise of marriage, he cannot demand the return of the engagement ring. Examples of legal justification include but may not be limited to other parties with violent predisposition or infidelity.
  • It matters not in law that the repudiation of the promise may turn out to be the ultimate advantage of both parties. A judge must apply the existing law as to the limits of justification for breach.
  • If the engagement to marry is dissolved by mutual consent, then in the absence of an agreement to the contrary, the engagement ring and gifts like gifts must be returned by each party to the other.

At first instance, the Court found that although Vicki rejected the gift (ie the engagement ring), and that she was in possession of it, she did not own it. Therefore, she was not entitled to instruct her father to throw the ring away.

On appeal, the Court agreed with the previous decision and confirmed that ‘an engagement had many characteristics of a commercial bargain. It is governed in large part by the principles of law applicable to ordinary contracts.’ Further:

“A like result to that I have already stated will follow if an engagement ring be regarded as a pledge or deposit for the fulfillment of a contract. A person who wrongly refuses to carry out a bargain will lose his deposit.” (citations omitted).

The present case is the reverse of that situation. If without legal justification the woman refuses to carry out her promise she cannot keep and must return the ring.

This means that Vicki’s actions of ending the engagement, meant that she lost her entitlement to the engagement ring. The fact that Andrew refused to take back the engagement ring was not a factor that was considered.

Vicki was ordered to pay Andrew the value of the engagement ring, as well as his legal costs.

At PCL Lawyers our family lawyers can help with a wide range of family and property settlement matters. Our team are experts in handling matters to achieve a successful resolution.

If you need advice in relation to a family law matter contact one of our family lawyers today to see how we can help.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
slot thailand slot dana 888slot slot zeus ladangtoto sv388 slot server kamboja slot server jepang slot deposit pulsa joker123 pg soft mahjong ways 2 888slot gb777 joker123 slot zeus slot rusia slot jepang slot zeus slot77 pg soft rtp slot slot thailand slot thailand slot88 nolimit city slot jepang slot kamboja slot777 rtp slot slot zeus slot server luar negeri sv388 mahjong ways 2 slot deposit dana slot deposit ovo pg soft sweet bonanza wild bandito thor megaways mahjong ways 2 slot deposit pulsa meong77 spaceman slot gopay slot ovo slot dana slot server kamboja slot server thailand slot server jepang slot thailand slot88 slot zeus slot server kamboja slot thailand slot kamboja slot jepang slot zeus rtp slot slot mahjong ways slot thailand slot zeus slot777 slot pulsa slot dana slot thailand slot88 ladangtoto slot mahjong ways slot thailand slot kamboja slot qris slot zeus pg soft slot88 mahjong ways 2 slot zeus slot server kamboja slot deposit dana slot deposit ovo slot deposit gopay slot dana nolimit city slot princess slot kamboja slot777 slot88 mahjong ways 2 slot thailand slot dana slot kamboja slot77 slot zeus slot luar negeri https://bpkad.muratarakab.go.id/public/hacksaw-idn/ https://bpkad.muratarakab.go.id/public/mandiri-gacor/ ASIA GAMING SLOT SEABANK SLOT SAKUKU slot dewa x500 https://bpkad.muratarakab.go.id/public/sjoker123/ sv388 starlight princess slot thailand slot kamboja slot jepang slot luar negeri slot777 slot zeus mahjong ways 2 slot888 rtp slot slot zeus slot88 slot zeus slot princess pg soft slot777 slot kamboja slot jepang slot rusia slot malaysia slot korea slot myanmar https://bpkad.muratarakab.go.id/public/smahjong/ SLOT NEOBANK SLOT LINKAJA AKUN PRO PLATINUM CHEAT SLOT https://sikerma.untirta.ac.id/application/libraries/pragmatic/ slot maxwin https://sikerma.untirta.ac.id/application/libraries/sgopay/ Pg Soft Starlight Princess Sv388 Joker123 Sbobet Slot88 RTP Slot Slot Dana Slot Ovo Slot Pulsa WS168 Ladangtoto slot bonanza SLOT JAGO slot777 https://sikerma.untirta.ac.id/_assets/sqris/ SLOT MAHJONG SLOT DEWA Slot Thailand Slot Zeus http://labse.ce.undip.ac.id/sejarah/gacorx/ Slot Thailand Starlight Princess Mahjong Ways 2 Slot Maxwin Slot Thailand Sv388 Joker123 Starlight Princess Mahjong Ways 2 Slot Maxwin SLOT MEGAWAYS SLOT TRIOFUS CHEAT SLOT SLOT MANDIRI SLOT GANAS SLOT LINKAJA ladangtoto SLOT DEWA ZEUS SLOT BANTENG SLOT MANTAP SLOT X500 Slot Thailand Slot Zeus Slot Thailand Slot Zeus Sv388 Pg Soft Starlight Princess Slot Thailand Slot Zeus Slot Thailand Slot Zeus slot thailand slot server luar negeri slot qris slot thailand akun pro kamboja akun pro jepang slot filipina slot rusia slot kamboja joker123 slot zeus slot88 888slot slot deposit pulsa mahjong ways 2 slot jepang slot dana slot luar negeri koi gate nolimit city slot thailand slot princess slot zeus slot77 ladangtoto slot thailand slot kamboja 888slot slot mahjong slot777 slot luar negeri slot zeus nolimit city ladangtoto sv388 slot88 slot thailand slot megaways slot ikan https://bpkad.muratarakab.go.id/system/core/s888/ https://bpkad.muratarakab.go.id/system/core/s777/ slot mania NEW SLOT POLA GACOR Joker123 Slot Thailand Slot Gacor Slot Zeus Slot Princess Slot Maxwin Pg Soft RTP Live Slot Pulsa Slot Server Luar Slot Thailand Mahjong Ways 2 Pg Soft Slot Zeus Sv388 Starlight Princess Joker123 Slot Maxwin Slot Ovo Slot Gopay Slot Bank BSI Gates Of Gatotkaca Twilight Princess Idn Slot Slot Toto Slot Anti Rungkad Slot Receh Slot Hoki Slot Asia Dewa Slot Depo Slot Raja Slot Nexus Slot Slot X500 Slot Dana Slot Server Luar Starlight Princess Slot Thailand Slot Hongkong Joker123 Slot Zeus Starlight Princess Sv388 Slot Thailand Slot Zeus Joker123 Sv388 Starlight Princess Mahjong Ways 2 Slot Hongkong Pg Soft Slot Zeus Sv388 Joker123 Slot Princess Slot Thailand Slot Thailand Slot Zeus Mahjong Ways 2 https://imwi.ac.id/assets/files/gacor-maxwin/ Slot Thailand Slot Zeus https://mandiri-gacor.angkolatimur.tapselkab.go.id/ jp slot slot ganas https://cheat-gacor.angkolatimur.tapselkab.go.id/ crazy time live slot qris https://sqris.angkolatimur.tapselkab.go.id/ slot akurat https://deposit-mandiri.pfn.co.id/ slot bca slot bni https://deposit-bri.pfn.co.id/ nolimit city slot thailand qris nolimit city slot korea slot zeus https://sibangkodir.bpsdm.jatimprov.go.id/vendor/phpspec/sqris/ nolimit city SLOT777 https://d3akt.feb.unri.ac.id/demo/ slot new terbaru https://rujak-bonanza.old.telusur.co.id/ slot gatot kaca https://bonanza-gold.old.telusur.co.id/ slot sugar rush https://x500-gacor.old.telusur.co.id/ https://server-luar-negeri.pfn.co.id/ https://bpusdataru-probolo.jatengprov.go.id/products/ server thailand https://pragmaticplay.dharmasatyasarana.co.id/ https://joker123.dharmasatyasarana.co.id/ https://pg-soft.dharmasatyasarana.co.id/ https://server-thailand.dharmasatyasarana.co.id/ https://dana.sidamaju.skom.id/ https://ovo.sidamaju.skom.id/ https://gopay.sidamaju.skom.id/ https://server-thailand.old.telusur.co.id/ https://server-kamboja.old.telusur.co.id/ https://server-rusia.old.telusur.co.id/ https://server-hongkong.old.telusur.co.id/ http://mahjong-ways.old.telusur.co.id/ https://idn.old.telusur.co.id/ https://starlight-princess.old.telusur.co.id/ https://zeus.old.telusur.co.id/ https://dana.old.telusur.co.id/ https://gacor88.old.telusur.co.id/ https://sabung-ayam-online.old.telusur.co.id/ https://pulsa.old.telusur.co.id/ https://pragmaticplay.old.telusur.co.id/ https://pg-soft.old.telusur.co.id/ https://joker123.putramuko.co.id/ https://akun-pro-rusia.mariyadl.sch.id/ https://ws168.putramuko.co.id/ https://pgsoft.putramuko.co.id/ sv388 joker123 zeus slot princess 1000 mahjong ways rtp slot slot88 server thailand sabung ayam online slot zeus pgsoft mahjong ways digmaan slot ovo joker123 server thailand ladangtoto slot zeus mahjong ways rtp slot slot princess sv388 joker123 digmaan powergaming88 powergaming88 powergaming88 server jepang server kamboja slot dana server thailand server hongkong slot ovo slot gopay slot linkaja joker123 nolimit city sv388 starlight princess mahjong ways pg slot slot zeus server thailand joker123 nolimit city slot dana sv388 server thailand joker123 sv388 mahjong ways zeusslot powergaming88 starlight princess idn slot 888 slot https://live-casino.pta-bali.go.id/ https://mi.pta-surabaya.go.id/mahjong-ways/ ladangtoto https://joker123.elearningmansatuokit.sch.id/ slot server thailand slot dubai slot malaysia slot kamboja sbobet sabung ayam online slot pragmatic zeus slot slot pg soft mahjong ways slot dana slot thailand 888 slot gacor88 gb777 ying77 66kbet ladangtoto2 slot thailand https://slot-thailand.itr.ac.id/ https://pn-watansoppeng.go.id/media/jui/server-thailand/ https://dinkes.hsu.go.id/wp-content/uploads/server-thailand/ ladangtoto slot thailand nolimit city koi gate zeus slot slot malaysia slot china slot rusia slot jepang slot amerika slot filipina slot dana sicbo online roulette online lice casino joker slot slot gacor maxwin slot mahjong slot303 live22 baccarat online slot hongkong slot303 slot88 nolimit city slot ovo slot gopay slot77 pragmati play starlight princess slot pg soft slot mahjong slot zeus slot thailand slot zeus starlight princess mahjong ways joker123 sv388 rtp slot slot dana slot ovo slot gopay nolimit city digmaan sabung ayam online powergaming88 powergaming88 slot kamboja slot dana pgsoft sabung ayam online slot princess slot777 slot jepang slot korea slot kamboja slot dana slot ovo joker123 rtp slot slot thailand slot zeus starlight princess mahjong ways joker123 sv388 rtp slot joker123 sabung ayam online slot pragmatic slot dana slot mahjong zeus slot slot thailand starlight princess slot pragmatic slot thailand sv388 joker123 slot zeus mahjong ways server thailand slot123 slot gacor slot dana slot mahjong slot maxwin slot pg soft gaming88 slot kamboja sabung ayam online slot mania slot zeus joker123 slot gacor slot jepang slot zeus akun vip slot pragmatic slot bet 100 sv388 mahjong ways pg soft slot maxwin zeus slot slot88 sv388 slot zeus slot princess sv388 pg soft mahjong ways slot zeus starlight princess joker123 slot thailand sv388 slot dana slot kamboja slot88 slot kamboja slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot dana slot thailand fafaslot sv388 slot zeus joker123 sv388 slot thailand pg soft mahjong ways slot zeus starlight princess rtp slot sv388 sabung ayam online 66kbet ying77 dewaslot ladangtoto gaming88 slot thailand slot maxwin gaming88 slot123 mahjong ways starlight princess joker123 slot pg zseus slot servee thailand 66kbet gaming88 ying77 ladangtoto dewaslot sabung ayam online slot thailand slot77 slot thailand server thailand slot88 slot maxwin slot thailand server thailand slot88 slot thailand slot mahjong slot88 slot zeus pg soft slot gacor maxwin sv388 joker123 ladangtoto 66kbet ying77 slot thailand server thailand slot maxwin slot88 pragmatic play judi bola live casino sv388 sbobet mahjong ways pragmaticplay sv388 sv388 pragmatic play slot gacor maxwin pg soft gates of olympus joker123 sv388 pg soft slot mahjong slot dana sv388 fafaslot idn poker joker123 mahjong ways sabung ayam online pg soft pragmatic slot petir slot olympus slot mania fafaslot slot mania fafaslot habanero ladangtoto ying77 66kbet gaming88 slot thailand server thailand sabung ayam online slot mania slot mahjong slot bet 200 slot dana slot hoki slot x500 slot pgsoft slot thailand slot kamboja slot jepang slot amerika slot mahjong slot gacor 2023 slot x500 ladangtoto slot server kamboja nolimit city digmaan slot thailand dewaslot digmaan sv388 slot joker123 mahjong ways 2 slot zeus starlight princess slot88 pg soft slot olympus 66kbet ladang toto ying77 gaming88 dewaslot pg soft 66kbet ying77 ladangtoto dewaslot scv388 sabung ayam online slot sabung ayam online live casino 66k ladangtoto digmaan slot pragmatic slot jepang slot china slot kamboja slot rusia slot malaysia slot amerika slot thailand slot zeus slot ovo slot dana slot gopay sicbo online roulette online joker123 slot mahjong tembak ikan online joker123 live casino slot123 66k ying77 ladangtoto sabung ayam online 66k ying77 ladangtoto live casino online sabung ayam online 66k ying77 ladangtoto slot thailand ladangtoto ladangtoto sv388 ladangtoto ladangtoto ladangtoto sv388 ladangtoto sv388 66kbet ying77 gaming88 dewaslot ladangtoto slot thailand slot thailand ladangtoto 66k bet ying77bet sv388 66kbet ying77 ladangtoto 66k one ladangtoto ying77 slot maxwin 66k bet ying77bet ladangtoto slot zeus slot thailand slot thailand server thailand slot thailand slot thailand server thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot gacor ladangtoto2 slot thailand server thailand ying77 bet ying77 ladangtoto 66k bet slot gacor server thailand slot88 slot gacor slot thailand slot88 slot thailand ying77 ying77 powergaming88 slot88 ladangtoto ladangtoto sabung ayam online slot thailand slot maxwin sv388 pg soft mahjong ways sv388 mahjong ways 2 sv388 slot thailand 66k bet slot sv388 ladangtoto slot zeus slot gacor dewaslot ladangtoto 66k bet slot dana sabung ayam online sabung ayam inline slot thailand slot thailand slot88 slot thailand slot pgsoft slot slot mahjong slot thailand fafaslot slot princess slot gopay slot toto slot server thailand slot thailand slot gacor slot server thailand slot thailand slot gacor slot kakek zeus Joker123 Mahjong Ways 2 Sv388 Sbobet Slot Dana Slot Thailand slot thailand situs slot wwg slot slot daftar judi slot online indonesia slot mahjong ways slot gacor slot mawin slot gacor slot thailand slot thailand slot gacor slot gacor slot gacor demo slot pragmatic sv388 slot88 pgsoft slot thailand slot gacor slot ovo Daftar Judi Slot Online Indonesia Paling Gacor di Indonesia Daftar Situs Judi Slot Online SLOT88 lucky neko slot gacor slot88 slot kakek slot dana slot maxwin slot server luar negeri slot thailand Slot Mahjong Ways 2 Mudah Jackpot Paus di PG Soft Hari ini 2023 Lucky Neko Situs Slot Gacor Pgsoft Hari Ini SITUS SABUNG AYAM SV388 ONLINE DAFTAR LINK LOGIN APK AGEN SV388 Daftar Judi Slot Online Indonesia Paling Gacor di Indonesia powergaming88