Smt. Sureshta Devi vs Om Prakash

Citations: 1992 AIR 1904, 1991 SCR(1) 274

Appellant: Smt. Sureshta Devi

Respondents: Om Prakash

Decided On: 7.02. 1991

Equivalent Citations:

1. 1992 AIR 1904

2. 1991 SCR (1) 274

Benches:

SHETTY, KJ (J)

AGRAWAL, SC (J)

Statutes Referred:

Hindu Marriage Act, 1955

Special Marriage Act, 1954

Marriage Laws (Amendment) Act, 1976

In a marriage, a man and woman make a lifelong commitment to one another, promising to love and cherish one another until death do them part. The pair learns the true meaning of love, trust, tolerance, support and harmony through their marriage as a union. It is a community of people where bonds are formed between not just two individuals but also two families. Divorce is the discontinuation of a marriage and there are a number of grounds for divorce and through mutual consent is one such ground.

One of the most sophisticated and decorative methods to dissolve a marriage is divorce by mutual consent[1]. Upon realizing that the wife and the husband cannot live together, they can mutually agree to dissolve the marriage with the help of this provision[2]. As compared to other methods of divorce, mutual consent is much easier for both parties, and much less complicated in litigation. It only requires consent to end the marriage, from both parties, and if convinced, the court can even decrease the time of this process.[3]

Mutual consent to divorce is a requirement for issuing a divorce decision and according to section 13B of the Hindu Marriage Act of 1955, “when a divorce is sought on the ground of mutual consent, such consent has not been obtained by force, fraud or undue influences”. [4]Mutual consent to divorce is a requirement for issuing a divorce decision. The court must need both parties’ consent in order to issue a divorce decree, and the mutual consent should remain in place until the divorce is finalized. If the Court is handed the power to issue a decree based only on the first petition, the notion of the concepts of mutuality and agreement to divorce are abandoned. In this case, the Supreme Court considers whether a party to a mutual consent divorce petition under section 13B of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, has the right to revoke their assent or if, once granted, it is irrevocable.

The respondent’s wife is the appellant in the current case. The ceremony took place on November 21st, 1968. According to reports, the pair only spent a brief month together from 9 December 1984 to 7 January 1985. The pair did not live together or act in a romantic manner throughout the brief month-long period when they were separated due to a court order.

In accordance with clause 13B of the Hindu Marriage Act of 1955, the couple filed a petition for divorce by mutual consent in the district court of Harimpur. On January 9, 1985, the district court entered statements from both parties.

The wife (appellant in this case) filed an application on January 15th, 1985, claiming that the Harimpur district court had taken her statement under duress and intimidation from her husband. The wife asked the court to dismiss the petition and declare that she would not be a party to the divorce by mutual consent. The High Court received an appeal of the district judge’s rulings, and it returned the matter to the district judge for additional review.

The district judge ultimately recruits the divorce petition. The District Judge’s decision was overturned by the High Court on appeal, and a judgment for the dissolution of the marriage by mutual consent was issued. The High Court made the observation that once a spouse consents to a divorce petition, they are unable to unilaterally withdraw that agrees. If the consent was given freely in the first place, the court would still be able to dissolve the marriage by mutual consent.

Therefore, the appeal was filed by the appellant before the Supreme Court.

ISSUES

Whether a party to a petition for divorce by mutual consent under Section 13B of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 (‘Act’) can unilaterally withdraw the consent or whether the consent once given is irrevocable?[5]

The three requirements for divorce by mutual consent under Subsection (1) of Section 13-B are:

1. The couple have been living separately for a period of one year.

2. The couple have not been able to live together.

3. The couple have mutually agreed to dissolve the marriage.[6]

Sub-section (2) of Section 13-B states that, “the parties are required to make a joint motion not earlier than six months after the date of presentation of the petition and not later than 18 months after the said date. This motion enables the Court to proceed with the case in order to satisfy itself about the genuineness of the opinions in the petition and also to find out whether the consent was not obtained by force, fraud or undue influence.”[7]

The question of whether a party to a mutual consent divorce case under Section 13B of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 can withdraw their consent or if consent is irrevocable once given has been debated by several high courts in India.

The Bombay High Court in Jayashree Ramesh Londhe v. Ramesh Bhikaji Londhe said that, “the crucial time for a party to give their consent for divorce by mutual consent under section 13-B is the time when the petition was filed given that such consent has not been obtained by force, fraud or undue influence .”[8]

The High Court of Delhi followed the same line of reasoning in Smt. Chander Kanta v. Hans Kumar and others[9]and the Madhya Pradesh High Court in Meena Dutta v. Anirudh Dutta[10], also took the same view.

While Rajasthan High Court in Santosh Kumari v. Virendra Kumar [11]and Kerala High Court in KL Mohanan v. Jeejabaiand [12]the Punjab and Haryana High court in Harcharan Kaur v. Nachhattar singh[13] , have ruled that any party may decide to end a marriage by mutual consent at any moment prior to the court issuing a judgment for the dissolution of the marriage. the pleasure of the court following a review of the admissibility of the consent inevitably has a revocation clause that either spouse may utilize.

In this case, the Indian Supreme Court upheld the judgment of the High Courts of Rajasthan, Kerala, Punjab, and Haryana and held that the concept of mutuality and consent of a partner for divorce would be rendered meaningless if the courts were given the authority to grant a divorce based solely on the couple’s initial court petition.

The Indian Supreme Court was correct to rule that the filing of a petition with mutual consent does not provide the court with the authority to grant a divorce decision. The 6- to 18-month waiting period outlined in Subsection (2) of Section 13-B is meant to allow the parties ample time to think over their decisions and consult with family and friends. One of the parties may change their minds and opt not to move further with the petition during this interim time. The spouse is prohibited from participating in the joint motion under paragraph (2). Nothing in the Section prohibits taking such a step. The Section does not need the other party to change their views if the first party does.

The court should be satisfied with the parties’ good faith and consent, according to the high courts of Rajasthan, Kerala, Punjab and Haryana. If there isn’t mutual consent at the time of the inquiry, the court lacks the jurisdiction to grant a divorce. If the Court has a different opinion, it may, at the request of one party and without the consent of the other, launch an inquiry and grant a divorce judgment. Such a ruling cannot be regarded as one that was reached via mutual consent.

The High Courts in Delhi and Mumbai have moved forward based on the reasoning that -When the petition is filed, not when they later seek for a divorce decree, is the important period for obtaining mutual consent for divorce. This strategy seems unworkable. The parties are aware that their petition does not automatically server the relationship at the moment of the petition by mutual consent. They are aware that they must go one step further to dissolve their marriage. This is made apparent in Subsection (2) of Section 13-B.

This clause’s requirement that mutual consent be present when they ask the court to grant a divorce order is crucial. Second, the Court must be convinced of the parties’ good faith and consent. The court lacks jurisdiction to provide a divorce decision if there is not mutual consent at the time of the inquiry.

The concept of mutuality and consent is completely destroyed if the Court is granted the authority to issue a decree simply based on the first petition.

Under Section 13-B, mutual assent to the divorce is a requirement for granting a divorce decree. Mutual consent should last until the divorce decree is granted.

The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Smt Sureshta Devi v. Om Prakash held that “a party to a mutual consent divorce petition under section 13B of Hindu marriage act, 1955 can withdraw their consent until the decree for dissolution of marriage is passed.”

There is no mention of your residence. The parties may not be living as husband and wife even if they may share a home because of certain conditions. They had been living apart for a year previously to the petition’s filing because of their inability or unwillingness to fulfill their marital obligations. As the Supreme Court has determined in several decisions, the phrase “have been living apart” need not imply a physical separation or distinct and separate living. The fact that couples are not upholding their marital duties and are not cohabiting as husband and wife is what concerns this.

The Bench carefully considered all the important elements and came to the conclusion that the mutual consent expressed at the time the divorce petition was filed was inadequate to provide the Court the authority to deliver a divorce judgment based on mutual consent. The parties must have the same mutual permission when filing a joint petition for divorce by mutual consent after six to eighteen months, at which time any party may withdraw their consent.


[1] 5Anil Malhotra & Ranjit Malhotra, Marriage and Divorce – Complete Constitutional Justice, 2015 INT’l Surv. FAM. L. 121 (2015).

[2] Sampak P. Garg, Law and Religion: The Divorce Systems of India, 6 Tulsa J. COMP. & INT’l L. 1 (1998).

[3] Amit Jain v. Cadets Jain, (2007) 147 PLR 114.

[4] The Hindu marriage act, 1955, §23(1)(bb), No. 25, Acts of Parliament, 1955 (India).

[5] Smt. Sureshta Devi vs Om Prakash 1992 AIR 1904, 1991 SCR (1) 274

[6] The Hindu marriage act, 1955, §13B(2), No. 25, Acts of Parliament, 1955 (India).

[7] Ibid

[8] Jayashree Ramesh Londhe v. Ramesh Bhikaji LondonAIR 1984 Bombay 302

[9] 9 Smt. Chander Kanta v. Hans Kumar and anr., AIR 1989 Delhi 73

[10] Meena Dutta v. Anirudh Dutta, (1984) II DMC 388

[11] Santosh Kumari v. Virendra Kumar, AIR 1986 Rajasthan 128

[12] KL Mohanan v. Jeejabai, AIR 1988 Kerala 28

[13] Harcharan Kaur v. Nachhattar singh, AIR (1987-2)92 PLR 224


Srijan Garg

Author

Srijan Garg hails from University of Petroleum and Energy Studies, Dehradun and spends most of his time researching on various laws and updates in the legal industry. For any clarifications, feedback, and advice, you can reach us at [email protected]

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
slot thailand slot dana 888slot slot zeus ladangtoto sv388 slot server kamboja slot server jepang slot deposit pulsa joker123 pg soft mahjong ways 2 888slot gb777 joker123 slot zeus slot rusia slot jepang slot zeus slot77 pg soft rtp slot slot thailand slot thailand slot88 nolimit city slot jepang slot kamboja slot777 rtp slot slot zeus slot server luar negeri sv388 mahjong ways 2 slot deposit dana slot deposit ovo pg soft sweet bonanza wild bandito thor megaways mahjong ways 2 slot deposit pulsa meong77 spaceman slot gopay slot ovo slot dana slot server kamboja slot server thailand slot server jepang slot thailand slot88 slot zeus slot server kamboja slot thailand slot kamboja slot jepang slot zeus rtp slot slot mahjong ways slot thailand slot zeus slot777 slot pulsa slot dana slot thailand slot88 ladangtoto slot mahjong ways slot thailand slot kamboja slot qris slot zeus pg soft slot88 mahjong ways 2 slot zeus slot server kamboja slot deposit dana slot deposit ovo slot deposit gopay slot dana nolimit city slot princess slot kamboja slot777 slot88 mahjong ways 2 slot thailand slot dana slot kamboja slot77 slot zeus slot luar negeri https://bpkad.muratarakab.go.id/public/hacksaw-idn/ https://bpkad.muratarakab.go.id/public/mandiri-gacor/ ASIA GAMING SLOT SEABANK SLOT SAKUKU slot dewa x500 https://bpkad.muratarakab.go.id/public/sjoker123/ sv388 starlight princess slot thailand slot kamboja slot jepang slot luar negeri slot777 slot zeus mahjong ways 2 slot888 rtp slot slot zeus slot88 slot zeus slot princess pg soft slot777 slot kamboja slot jepang slot rusia slot malaysia slot korea slot myanmar https://bpkad.muratarakab.go.id/public/smahjong/ SLOT NEOBANK SLOT LINKAJA AKUN PRO PLATINUM CHEAT SLOT https://sikerma.untirta.ac.id/application/libraries/pragmatic/ slot maxwin https://sikerma.untirta.ac.id/application/libraries/sgopay/ Pg Soft Starlight Princess Sv388 Joker123 Sbobet Slot88 RTP Slot Slot Dana Slot Ovo Slot Pulsa WS168 Ladangtoto slot bonanza SLOT JAGO slot777 https://sikerma.untirta.ac.id/_assets/sqris/ SLOT MAHJONG SLOT DEWA Slot Thailand Slot Zeus http://labse.ce.undip.ac.id/sejarah/gacorx/ Slot Thailand Starlight Princess Mahjong Ways 2 Slot Maxwin Slot Thailand Sv388 Joker123 Starlight Princess Mahjong Ways 2 Slot Maxwin SLOT MEGAWAYS SLOT TRIOFUS CHEAT SLOT SLOT MANDIRI SLOT GANAS SLOT LINKAJA ladangtoto SLOT DEWA ZEUS SLOT BANTENG SLOT MANTAP SLOT X500 Slot Thailand Slot Zeus Slot Thailand Slot Zeus Sv388 Pg Soft Starlight Princess Slot Thailand Slot Zeus Slot Thailand Slot Zeus slot thailand slot server luar negeri slot qris slot thailand akun pro kamboja akun pro jepang slot filipina slot rusia slot kamboja joker123 slot zeus slot88 888slot slot deposit pulsa mahjong ways 2 slot jepang slot dana slot luar negeri koi gate nolimit city slot thailand slot princess slot zeus slot77 ladangtoto slot thailand slot kamboja 888slot slot mahjong slot777 slot luar negeri slot zeus nolimit city ladangtoto sv388 slot88 slot thailand slot megaways slot ikan https://bpkad.muratarakab.go.id/system/core/s888/ https://bpkad.muratarakab.go.id/system/core/s777/ slot mania NEW SLOT POLA GACOR Joker123 Slot Thailand Slot Gacor Slot Zeus Slot Princess Slot Maxwin Pg Soft RTP Live Slot Pulsa Slot Server Luar Slot Thailand Mahjong Ways 2 Pg Soft Slot Zeus Sv388 Starlight Princess Joker123 Slot Maxwin Slot Ovo Slot Gopay Slot Bank BSI Gates Of Gatotkaca Twilight Princess Idn Slot Slot Toto Slot Anti Rungkad Slot Receh Slot Hoki Slot Asia Dewa Slot Depo Slot Raja Slot Nexus Slot Slot X500 Slot Dana Slot Server Luar Starlight Princess Slot Thailand Slot Hongkong Joker123 Slot Zeus Starlight Princess Sv388 Slot Thailand Slot Zeus Joker123 Sv388 Starlight Princess Mahjong Ways 2 Slot Hongkong Pg Soft Slot Zeus Sv388 Joker123 Slot Princess Slot Thailand Slot Thailand Slot Zeus Mahjong Ways 2 https://imwi.ac.id/assets/files/gacor-maxwin/ Slot Thailand Slot Zeus https://mandiri-gacor.angkolatimur.tapselkab.go.id/ jp slot slot ganas https://cheat-gacor.angkolatimur.tapselkab.go.id/ crazy time live slot qris https://sqris.angkolatimur.tapselkab.go.id/ slot akurat https://deposit-mandiri.pfn.co.id/ slot bca slot bni https://deposit-bri.pfn.co.id/ nolimit city slot thailand qris nolimit city slot korea slot zeus https://sibangkodir.bpsdm.jatimprov.go.id/vendor/phpspec/sqris/ nolimit city SLOT777 https://d3akt.feb.unri.ac.id/demo/ slot new terbaru https://rujak-bonanza.old.telusur.co.id/ slot gatot kaca https://bonanza-gold.old.telusur.co.id/ slot sugar rush https://x500-gacor.old.telusur.co.id/ https://server-luar-negeri.pfn.co.id/ https://bpusdataru-probolo.jatengprov.go.id/products/ server thailand https://pragmaticplay.dharmasatyasarana.co.id/ https://joker123.dharmasatyasarana.co.id/ https://pg-soft.dharmasatyasarana.co.id/ https://server-thailand.dharmasatyasarana.co.id/ https://dana.sidamaju.skom.id/ https://ovo.sidamaju.skom.id/ https://gopay.sidamaju.skom.id/ https://server-thailand.old.telusur.co.id/ https://server-kamboja.old.telusur.co.id/ https://server-rusia.old.telusur.co.id/ https://server-hongkong.old.telusur.co.id/ http://mahjong-ways.old.telusur.co.id/ https://idn.old.telusur.co.id/ https://starlight-princess.old.telusur.co.id/ https://zeus.old.telusur.co.id/ https://dana.old.telusur.co.id/ https://gacor88.old.telusur.co.id/ https://sabung-ayam-online.old.telusur.co.id/ https://pulsa.old.telusur.co.id/ https://pragmaticplay.old.telusur.co.id/ https://pg-soft.old.telusur.co.id/ https://joker123.putramuko.co.id/ https://akun-pro-rusia.mariyadl.sch.id/ https://ws168.putramuko.co.id/ https://pgsoft.putramuko.co.id/ sv388 joker123 zeus slot princess 1000 mahjong ways rtp slot slot88 server thailand sabung ayam online slot zeus pgsoft mahjong ways digmaan slot ovo joker123 server thailand ladangtoto slot zeus mahjong ways rtp slot slot princess sv388 joker123 digmaan powergaming88 powergaming88 powergaming88 server jepang server kamboja slot dana server thailand server hongkong slot ovo slot gopay slot linkaja joker123 nolimit city sv388 starlight princess mahjong ways pg slot slot zeus server thailand joker123 nolimit city slot dana sv388 server thailand joker123 sv388 mahjong ways zeusslot powergaming88 starlight princess idn slot 888 slot https://live-casino.pta-bali.go.id/ https://mi.pta-surabaya.go.id/mahjong-ways/ ladangtoto https://joker123.elearningmansatuokit.sch.id/ slot server thailand slot dubai slot malaysia slot kamboja sbobet sabung ayam online slot pragmatic zeus slot slot pg soft mahjong ways slot dana slot thailand 888 slot gacor88 gb777 ying77 66kbet ladangtoto2 slot thailand https://slot-thailand.itr.ac.id/ https://pn-watansoppeng.go.id/media/jui/server-thailand/ https://dinkes.hsu.go.id/wp-content/uploads/server-thailand/ ladangtoto slot thailand nolimit city koi gate zeus slot slot malaysia slot china slot rusia slot jepang slot amerika slot filipina slot dana sicbo online roulette online lice casino joker slot slot gacor maxwin slot mahjong slot303 live22 baccarat online slot hongkong slot303 slot88 nolimit city slot ovo slot gopay slot77 pragmati play starlight princess slot pg soft slot mahjong slot zeus slot thailand slot zeus starlight princess mahjong ways joker123 sv388 rtp slot slot dana slot ovo slot gopay nolimit city digmaan sabung ayam online powergaming88 powergaming88 slot kamboja slot dana pgsoft sabung ayam online slot princess slot777 slot jepang slot korea slot kamboja slot dana slot ovo joker123 rtp slot slot thailand slot zeus starlight princess mahjong ways joker123 sv388 rtp slot joker123 sabung ayam online slot pragmatic slot dana slot mahjong zeus slot slot thailand starlight princess slot pragmatic slot thailand sv388 joker123 slot zeus mahjong ways server thailand slot123 slot gacor slot dana slot mahjong slot maxwin slot pg soft gaming88 slot kamboja sabung ayam online slot mania slot zeus joker123 slot gacor slot jepang slot zeus akun vip slot pragmatic slot bet 100 sv388 mahjong ways pg soft slot maxwin zeus slot slot88 sv388 slot zeus slot princess sv388 pg soft mahjong ways slot zeus starlight princess joker123 slot thailand sv388 slot dana slot kamboja slot88 slot kamboja slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot dana slot thailand fafaslot sv388 slot zeus joker123 sv388 slot thailand pg soft mahjong ways slot zeus starlight princess rtp slot sv388 sabung ayam online 66kbet ying77 dewaslot ladangtoto gaming88 slot thailand slot maxwin gaming88 slot123 mahjong ways starlight princess joker123 slot pg zseus slot servee thailand 66kbet gaming88 ying77 ladangtoto dewaslot sabung ayam online slot thailand slot77 slot thailand server thailand slot88 slot maxwin slot thailand server thailand slot88 slot thailand slot mahjong slot88 slot zeus pg soft slot gacor maxwin sv388 joker123 ladangtoto 66kbet ying77 slot thailand server thailand slot maxwin slot88 pragmatic play judi bola live casino sv388 sbobet mahjong ways pragmaticplay sv388 sv388 pragmatic play slot gacor maxwin pg soft gates of olympus joker123 sv388 pg soft slot mahjong slot dana sv388 fafaslot idn poker joker123 mahjong ways sabung ayam online pg soft pragmatic slot petir slot olympus slot mania fafaslot slot mania fafaslot habanero ladangtoto ying77 66kbet gaming88 slot thailand server thailand sabung ayam online slot mania slot mahjong slot bet 200 slot dana slot hoki slot x500 slot pgsoft slot thailand slot kamboja slot jepang slot amerika slot mahjong slot gacor 2023 slot x500 ladangtoto slot server kamboja nolimit city digmaan slot thailand dewaslot digmaan sv388 slot joker123 mahjong ways 2 slot zeus starlight princess slot88 pg soft slot olympus 66kbet ladang toto ying77 gaming88 dewaslot pg soft 66kbet ying77 ladangtoto dewaslot scv388 sabung ayam online slot sabung ayam online live casino 66k ladangtoto digmaan slot pragmatic slot jepang slot china slot kamboja slot rusia slot malaysia slot amerika slot thailand slot zeus slot ovo slot dana slot gopay sicbo online roulette online joker123 slot mahjong tembak ikan online joker123 live casino slot123 66k ying77 ladangtoto sabung ayam online 66k ying77 ladangtoto live casino online sabung ayam online 66k ying77 ladangtoto slot thailand ladangtoto ladangtoto sv388 ladangtoto ladangtoto ladangtoto sv388 ladangtoto sv388 66kbet ying77 gaming88 dewaslot ladangtoto slot thailand slot thailand ladangtoto 66k bet ying77bet sv388 66kbet ying77 ladangtoto 66k one ladangtoto ying77 slot maxwin 66k bet ying77bet ladangtoto slot zeus slot thailand slot thailand server thailand slot thailand slot thailand server thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot gacor ladangtoto2 slot thailand server thailand ying77 bet ying77 ladangtoto 66k bet slot gacor server thailand slot88 slot gacor slot thailand slot88 slot thailand ying77 ying77 powergaming88 slot88 ladangtoto ladangtoto sabung ayam online slot thailand slot maxwin sv388 pg soft mahjong ways sv388 mahjong ways 2 sv388 slot thailand 66k bet slot sv388 ladangtoto slot zeus slot gacor dewaslot ladangtoto 66k bet slot dana sabung ayam online sabung ayam inline slot thailand slot thailand slot88 slot thailand slot pgsoft slot slot mahjong slot thailand fafaslot slot princess slot gopay slot toto slot server thailand slot thailand slot gacor slot server thailand slot thailand slot gacor slot kakek zeus Joker123 Mahjong Ways 2 Sv388 Sbobet Slot Dana Slot Thailand slot thailand situs slot wwg slot slot daftar judi slot online indonesia slot mahjong ways slot gacor slot mawin slot gacor slot thailand slot thailand slot gacor slot gacor slot gacor demo slot pragmatic sv388 slot88 pgsoft slot thailand slot gacor slot ovo Daftar Judi Slot Online Indonesia Paling Gacor di Indonesia Daftar Situs Judi Slot Online SLOT88 lucky neko slot gacor slot88 slot kakek slot dana slot maxwin slot server luar negeri slot thailand Slot Mahjong Ways 2 Mudah Jackpot Paus di PG Soft Hari ini 2023 Lucky Neko Situs Slot Gacor Pgsoft Hari Ini SITUS SABUNG AYAM SV388 ONLINE DAFTAR LINK LOGIN APK AGEN SV388 Daftar Judi Slot Online Indonesia Paling Gacor di Indonesia powergaming88