Client Legal Update: Judgment of the Federal Labor Court (BAG)

See below this judgment from 20 December 2022 on the merits and limitations of annual vacation entitlements.

Summary

  • On 20 December 2022, the German Federal Labor Court (“BAG”) ruled that the entitlement to statutory minimum vacation is only subject to the three-year year statute of limitations if the employer has (i) previously informed its employees about their specific vacation entitlements and that the vacation will lapse if they do not take it and (ii) the employee then freely decides not to take them (See judgment – 9 AZR 266/20).
  • If the employer fails to do so, the corresponding vacation claims of the employees from earlier years can still be asserted.
  • The employer cannot rely on the regular three-year statute of limitation period (Sections 195, 199 German Civil Code (“BGB)”) as the statute of limitation period only begins at the end of the calendar year in which the employer is properly informed the employees.
  • With guidance by the European Court of Justice (“ECJ”), the BAG is thus continuously implementing an employee-friendly interpretation of the national vacation law.
  • Employers must pay attention to explicitly pointing out existing vacation entitlements of employees in a timely manner and to remind employees of their expiration in a documented way.
  • Otherwise, there is a risk that employees will accumulate endless vacation days over the year, which must be either granted or paid out at the end of the employment.
  • So far only the BAG press release of the judgment is available but as you can see it already contains very significant statements

Background of the decision

  • According to German law the annual vacation must in principle be taken in the current calendar year (Section 7 (3) German Federal Holiday Act (BUrlG)) – otherwise it is forfeited. From this rule there are 3 main exceptions:
    • Exception 1: the vacation does not lapse if the employee is sick throughout the whole calendar year. Then the vacation lapses after 15 months.
    • Exception 2: An automatic carryover of vacation until 31 March of the following year takes place if there are urgent compelling operational reasons or personal reasons that prevented an employee from taking the vacation
    • Exception 3: the employer did not timely inform the employee about the lapse on 31 December, did not ask them to take the vacation and did not make sure the employee could actually take the vacation
  • The right to paid annual vacation is further guaranteed in Art. 31 (2) of the Charter of Fundamental Rights. Additional regulations can also be found in Art. 7 of the Working Time Directive RL 2003/88/EC and numerous decisions on its interpretation by the ECJ. Questions of vacation law are therefore not to be judged solely according to national law.
  • In 2018, the ECJ ruled that annual leave entitlements can only be forfeited if the employee is “actually put in a position by his or her employer to also exercise the leave entitlement by providing the appropriate information” (judgment of 6 November 2018 – C- 684/16).
  • The BAG followed up on this decision and established a strict information and clarification obligation (duty to cooperate) of the employer: Only if the employer has pointed out the existence and expiry date of vacation entitlements and the employee has nevertheless not taken leave of his or her her own free will, shall it be forfeited (judgment of 19 February 2019 – 9 AZR 423/16).
  • The question of how this case law relates to the statute of limitations was unresolved until now.
  • In principle, the regular limitation period is three years and begins – irrespective of knowledge of the claim – at the end of the calendar year in which it arose (Sections 195, 199 (1) BGB.
  • According to the new BAG decision, however, Section 199 (1) BGB is to be interpreted in accordance with the European directive.
  • Therefore, the regular limitation period of three years does not necessarily begin at the end of the vacation year, but only at the end of the year in which the employer fulfills its information and cooperation duties.

Practical implications

  • The decision is of fundamental importance for practice and emphasizes – once again – the significance of the employer’s obligations in regards to the granting of annual vacation.
  • Strict attention must be paid to informing employees in good time about existing vacation entitlements and their expiry, ie during the current calendar year or – if applicable – in the respective transition period (31st March of the following calendar year).
  • This applies in principle to statutory minimum leave as well as contractual additional leave, unless otherwise agreed on beforehand.
  • The employer must have actually made it possible for the employee to take the vacation. Thus, the employer must not have rejected the employee’s leave request for operational reasons.
  • Notification must be provided in a verifiable form and on an individual basis each calendar year. Blanket notifications or blanket agreements in the employment contract are not sufficient to fulfill the duty to cooperate.
  • It must also be checked whether vacation entitlements from the past calendar years have not expired due to non-fulfillment of the duty to cooperate, which must then be included in the notification. The employer may not invoke the fact that old vacation entitlements from periods prior to this case law have been forfeited.
  • The previous judicature according to which vacation entitlements expire automatically 15 months after the end of the calendar year in the event of uninterrupted incapacity for work because of sickness does not apply if (any) work was actually performed (at least in part) and the employer did not fulfill its duty to cooperate.
  • In consequence, vacation entitlements can accumulate if the duty to cooperate is not fulfilled. Meaning, if the employer fails to comply with these obligations, this can have significant costly consequences for the employer.
  • Although, the BAG has not expressed any opinion on this matter, a claim to compensation for unused vacation that has arisen as a result of the termination of the employment relationship is – as a purely monetary claim – likely to remain subject to the regular statute of limitations and/or exclusion periods.

To do’s for employers

  • The decision is of fundamental importance for practice and emphasizes – once again – the significance of the employer’s obligations in regards to the granting of annual vacation.
  • Strict attention must be paid to informing employees in good time about existing vacation entitlements and their expiry, ie during the current calendar year or – if applicable – in the respective transition period (31st March of the following calendar year).
  • This applies in principle to statutory minimum leave as well as contractual additional leave, unless otherwise agreed on beforehand.
  • The employer must have actually made it possible for the employee to take the vacation. Thus, the employer must not have rejected the employee’s leave request for operational reasons.
  • Notification must be provided in a verifiable form and on an individual basis each calendar year. Blanket notifications or blanket agreements in the employment contract are not sufficient to fulfill the duty to cooperate.
  • It must also be checked whether vacation entitlements from the past calendar years have not expired due to non-fulfillment of the duty to cooperate, which must then be included in the notification. The employer may not invoke the fact that old vacation entitlements from periods prior to this case law have been forfeited.
  • The previous judicature according to which vacation entitlements expire automatically 15 months after the end of the calendar year in the event of uninterrupted incapacity for work because of sickness does not apply if (any) work was actually performed (at least in part) and the employer did not fulfill its duty to cooperate.
  • In consequence, vacation entitlements can accumulate if the duty to cooperate is not fulfilled. Meaning, if the employer fails to comply with these obligations, this can have significant costly consequences for the employer.
  • Although, the BAG has not expressed any opinion on this matter, a claim to compensation for unused vacation that has arisen as a result of the termination of the employment relationship is – as a purely monetary claim – likely to remain subject to the regular statute of limitations and/or exclusion periods.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top
slot korea slot princess slot thailand rtp slot ladangtoto 888slot slot zeus slot thailand slot kamboja mahjong ways 2 slot deposit pulsa 888slot sv388 ladangtoto slot luar negeri slot deposit qris slot thailand slot deposit dana slot jepang rtp slot joker123 slot kamboja slot gatot kaca https://penghargaan.kemenkopukm.go.id/demo/ slot thailand slot dana 888slot slot zeus ladangtoto sv388 slot server kamboja slot server jepang slot deposit pulsa joker123 pg soft mahjong ways 2 888slot gb777 joker123 slot zeus slot rusia slot jepang slot zeus slot77 pg soft rtp slot slot thailand slot thailand slot88 nolimit city slot jepang slot kamboja slot777 rtp slot slot zeus slot server luar negeri sv388 mahjong ways 2 slot deposit dana slot deposit ovo pg soft sweet bonanza wild bandito thor megaways mahjong ways 2 slot deposit pulsa meong77 spaceman slot gopay slot ovo slot dana slot server kamboja slot server thailand slot server jepang slot thailand slot88 slot zeus slot server kamboja slot thailand slot kamboja slot jepang slot zeus rtp slot slot mahjong ways slot thailand slot zeus slot777 slot pulsa slot dana slot thailand slot88 ladangtoto slot mahjong ways slot thailand slot kamboja slot qris slot zeus pg soft slot88 mahjong ways 2 slot zeus slot server kamboja slot deposit dana slot deposit ovo slot deposit gopay slot dana nolimit city slot princess slot kamboja slot777 slot88 mahjong ways 2 slot thailand slot dana slot kamboja slot77 slot zeus slot luar negeri https://bpkad.muratarakab.go.id/public/hacksaw-idn/ https://bpkad.muratarakab.go.id/public/mandiri-gacor/ ASIA GAMING SLOT SEABANK SLOT SAKUKU slot dewa x500 https://bpkad.muratarakab.go.id/public/sjoker123/ sv388 starlight princess slot thailand slot kamboja slot jepang slot luar negeri slot777 slot zeus mahjong ways 2 slot888 rtp slot slot zeus slot88 slot zeus slot princess pg soft slot777 slot kamboja slot jepang slot rusia slot malaysia slot korea slot myanmar https://bpkad.muratarakab.go.id/public/smahjong/ SLOT NEOBANK SLOT LINKAJA AKUN PRO PLATINUM CHEAT SLOT https://sikerma.untirta.ac.id/application/libraries/pragmatic/ slot maxwin https://sikerma.untirta.ac.id/application/libraries/sgopay/ Slot Thailand Slot Zeus http://labse.ce.undip.ac.id/sejarah/gacorx/ Slot Thailand Starlight Princess Mahjong Ways 2 Slot Maxwin Slot Thailand Sv388 Joker123 Starlight Princess Mahjong Ways 2 Slot Maxwin SLOT MEGAWAYS SLOT TRIOFUS CHEAT SLOT SLOT MANDIRI SLOT GANAS SLOT LINKAJA ladangtoto SLOT DEWA ZEUS SLOT BANTENG SLOT MANTAP SLOT X500 Slot Thailand Slot Zeus Slot Thailand Slot Zeus Sv388 Pg Soft Starlight Princess Slot Thailand Slot Zeus slot thailand slot server luar negeri slot qris slot thailand akun pro kamboja akun pro jepang slot filipina slot rusia slot kamboja joker123 slot zeus slot88 888slot slot deposit pulsa mahjong ways 2 slot jepang slot dana slot luar negeri koi gate nolimit city slot thailand slot princess slot zeus slot77 ladangtoto slot thailand slot kamboja slot mahjong slot777 slot thailand slot megaways slot ikan https://bpkad.muratarakab.go.id/system/core/s888/ https://bpkad.muratarakab.go.id/system/core/s777/ slot mania NEW SLOT POLA GACOR Joker123 Slot Thailand Slot Gacor Slot Zeus Slot Princess Slot Maxwin Pg Soft RTP Live Slot Pulsa Slot Server Luar Slot Thailand Mahjong Ways 2 Pg Soft Slot Zeus Sv388 Starlight Princess Joker123 Slot Maxwin Slot Ovo Slot Gopay Slot Bank BSI Gates Of Gatotkaca Twilight Princess Idn Slot Slot Toto Slot Anti Rungkad Slot Receh Slot Hoki Slot Asia Dewa Slot Depo Slot Raja Slot Nexus Slot Slot X500 Slot Dana Slot Server Luar Starlight Princess Slot Thailand Slot Hongkong Joker123 Slot Zeus Starlight Princess Sv388 Slot Thailand Slot Zeus Joker123 Sv388 Starlight Princess Mahjong Ways 2 Slot Hongkong Pg Soft Slot Zeus Sv388 Joker123 Slot Princess Slot Thailand Slot Thailand Slot Zeus Mahjong Ways 2 https://imwi.ac.id/assets/files/gacor-maxwin/ Slot Thailand Slot Zeus https://mandiri-gacor.angkolatimur.tapselkab.go.id/ jp slot slot ganas https://cheat-gacor.angkolatimur.tapselkab.go.id/ crazy time live slot qris https://sqris.angkolatimur.tapselkab.go.id/ slot akurat https://deposit-mandiri.pfn.co.id/ slot bca slot bni https://deposit-bri.pfn.co.id/ nolimit city slot thailand qris nolimit city slot korea slot zeus https://sibangkodir.bpsdm.jatimprov.go.id/vendor/phpspec/sqris/ nolimit city SLOT777 https://d3akt.feb.unri.ac.id/demo/ slot new terbaru https://rujak-bonanza.old.telusur.co.id/ slot gatot kaca https://bonanza-gold.old.telusur.co.id/ slot sugar rush https://x500-gacor.old.telusur.co.id/ https://server-luar-negeri.pfn.co.id/ https://bpusdataru-probolo.jatengprov.go.id/products/ server thailand https://pragmaticplay.dharmasatyasarana.co.id/ https://joker123.dharmasatyasarana.co.id/ https://pg-soft.dharmasatyasarana.co.id/ https://server-thailand.dharmasatyasarana.co.id/ https://dana.sidamaju.skom.id/ https://ovo.sidamaju.skom.id/ https://gopay.sidamaju.skom.id/ https://server-thailand.old.telusur.co.id/ https://server-kamboja.old.telusur.co.id/ https://server-rusia.old.telusur.co.id/ https://server-hongkong.old.telusur.co.id/ http://mahjong-ways.old.telusur.co.id/ https://idn.old.telusur.co.id/ https://starlight-princess.old.telusur.co.id/ https://zeus.old.telusur.co.id/ https://dana.old.telusur.co.id/ https://gacor88.old.telusur.co.id/ https://sabung-ayam-online.old.telusur.co.id/ https://pulsa.old.telusur.co.id/ https://pragmaticplay.old.telusur.co.id/ https://pg-soft.old.telusur.co.id/ https://joker123.putramuko.co.id/ https://akun-pro-rusia.mariyadl.sch.id/ https://ws168.putramuko.co.id/ https://pgsoft.putramuko.co.id/ sv388 joker123 zeus slot princess 1000 mahjong ways rtp slot slot88 server thailand sabung ayam online slot zeus pgsoft mahjong ways digmaan slot ovo joker123 server thailand ladangtoto slot zeus mahjong ways rtp slot slot princess sv388 joker123 digmaan powergaming88 powergaming88 powergaming88 server jepang server kamboja slot dana server thailand server hongkong slot ovo slot gopay slot linkaja joker123 nolimit city sv388 starlight princess mahjong ways pg slot slot zeus server thailand joker123 nolimit city slot dana sv388 server thailand joker123 sv388 mahjong ways zeusslot powergaming88 starlight princess idn slot 888 slot https://live-casino.pta-bali.go.id/ https://mi.pta-surabaya.go.id/mahjong-ways/ ladangtoto https://joker123.elearningmansatuokit.sch.id/ slot server thailand slot dubai slot malaysia slot kamboja sbobet sabung ayam online slot pragmatic zeus slot slot pg soft mahjong ways slot dana slot thailand 888 slot gacor88 gb777 ying77 66kbet ladangtoto2 slot thailand https://slot-thailand.itr.ac.id/ https://pn-watansoppeng.go.id/media/jui/server-thailand/ https://dinkes.hsu.go.id/wp-content/uploads/server-thailand/ ladangtoto slot thailand nolimit city koi gate zeus slot slot malaysia slot china slot rusia slot jepang slot amerika slot filipina slot dana sicbo online roulette online lice casino joker slot slot gacor maxwin slot mahjong slot303 live22 baccarat online slot hongkong slot303 slot88 nolimit city slot ovo slot gopay slot77 pragmati play starlight princess slot pg soft slot mahjong slot zeus slot thailand slot zeus starlight princess mahjong ways joker123 sv388 rtp slot slot dana slot ovo slot gopay nolimit city digmaan sabung ayam online powergaming88 powergaming88 slot kamboja slot dana pgsoft sabung ayam online slot princess slot777 slot jepang slot korea slot kamboja slot dana slot ovo joker123 rtp slot slot thailand slot zeus starlight princess mahjong ways joker123 sv388 rtp slot joker123 sabung ayam online slot pragmatic slot dana slot mahjong zeus slot slot thailand starlight princess slot pragmatic slot thailand sv388 joker123 slot zeus mahjong ways server thailand slot123 slot gacor slot dana slot mahjong slot maxwin slot pg soft gaming88 slot kamboja sabung ayam online slot mania slot zeus joker123 slot gacor slot jepang slot zeus akun vip slot pragmatic slot bet 100 sv388 mahjong ways pg soft slot maxwin zeus slot slot88 sv388 slot zeus slot princess sv388 pg soft mahjong ways slot zeus starlight princess joker123 slot thailand sv388 slot dana slot kamboja slot88 slot kamboja slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot dana slot thailand fafaslot sv388 slot zeus joker123 sv388 slot thailand pg soft mahjong ways slot zeus starlight princess rtp slot sv388 sabung ayam online 66kbet ying77 dewaslot ladangtoto gaming88 slot thailand slot maxwin gaming88 slot123 mahjong ways starlight princess joker123 slot pg zseus slot servee thailand 66kbet gaming88 ying77 ladangtoto dewaslot sabung ayam online slot thailand slot77 slot thailand server thailand slot88 slot maxwin slot thailand server thailand slot88 slot thailand slot mahjong slot88 slot zeus pg soft slot gacor maxwin sv388 joker123 ladangtoto 66kbet ying77 slot thailand server thailand slot maxwin slot88 pragmatic play judi bola live casino sv388 sbobet mahjong ways pragmaticplay sv388 sv388 pragmatic play slot gacor maxwin pg soft gates of olympus joker123 sv388 pg soft slot mahjong slot dana sv388 fafaslot idn poker joker123 mahjong ways sabung ayam online pg soft pragmatic slot petir slot olympus slot mania fafaslot slot mania fafaslot habanero ladangtoto ying77 66kbet gaming88 slot thailand server thailand sabung ayam online slot mania slot mahjong slot bet 200 slot dana slot hoki slot x500 slot pgsoft slot thailand slot kamboja slot jepang slot amerika slot mahjong slot gacor 2023 slot x500 ladangtoto slot server kamboja nolimit city digmaan slot thailand dewaslot digmaan sv388 slot joker123 mahjong ways 2 slot zeus starlight princess slot88 pg soft slot olympus 66kbet ladang toto ying77 gaming88 dewaslot pg soft 66kbet ying77 ladangtoto dewaslot scv388 sabung ayam online slot sabung ayam online live casino 66k ladangtoto digmaan slot pragmatic slot jepang slot china slot kamboja slot rusia slot malaysia slot amerika slot thailand slot zeus slot ovo slot dana slot gopay sicbo online roulette online joker123 slot mahjong tembak ikan online joker123 live casino slot123 66k ying77 ladangtoto sabung ayam online 66k ying77 ladangtoto live casino online sabung ayam online 66k ying77 ladangtoto slot thailand ladangtoto ladangtoto sv388 ladangtoto ladangtoto ladangtoto sv388 ladangtoto sv388 66kbet ying77 gaming88 dewaslot ladangtoto slot thailand slot thailand ladangtoto 66k bet ying77bet sv388 66kbet ying77 ladangtoto 66k one ladangtoto ying77 slot maxwin 66k bet ying77bet ladangtoto slot zeus slot thailand slot thailand server thailand slot thailand slot thailand server thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot thailand slot gacor ladangtoto2 slot thailand server thailand ying77 bet ying77 ladangtoto 66k bet slot gacor server thailand slot88 slot gacor slot thailand slot88 slot thailand ying77 ying77 powergaming88 slot88 ladangtoto ladangtoto sabung ayam online slot thailand slot maxwin sv388 pg soft mahjong ways sv388 mahjong ways 2 sv388 slot thailand 66k bet slot sv388 ladangtoto slot zeus slot gacor dewaslot ladangtoto 66k bet slot dana sabung ayam online sabung ayam inline slot thailand slot thailand slot88 slot thailand slot pgsoft slot slot mahjong slot thailand fafaslot slot princess slot gopay slot toto slot server thailand slot thailand slot gacor slot server thailand slot thailand slot gacor slot kakek zeus Joker123 Mahjong Ways 2 Sv388 Sbobet Slot Dana Slot Thailand slot thailand situs slot wwg slot slot daftar judi slot online indonesia slot mahjong ways slot gacor slot mawin slot gacor slot thailand slot thailand slot gacor slot gacor slot gacor demo slot pragmatic sv388 slot88 pgsoft slot thailand slot gacor slot ovo Daftar Judi Slot Online Indonesia Paling Gacor di Indonesia Daftar Situs Judi Slot Online SLOT88 lucky neko slot gacor slot88 slot kakek slot dana slot maxwin slot server luar negeri slot thailand Slot Mahjong Ways 2 Mudah Jackpot Paus di PG Soft Hari ini 2023 Lucky Neko Situs Slot Gacor Pgsoft Hari Ini SITUS SABUNG AYAM SV388 ONLINE DAFTAR LINK LOGIN APK AGEN SV388 Daftar Judi Slot Online Indonesia Paling Gacor di Indonesia powergaming88